Architect, general contractor or project manager, which should you choose in Geneva?
Planning building work? Apartment, house or building renovation, a new storey or a roof extension, running the project is our job.
These three do different jobs and can work together. The architect designs the project, the general contractor builds it for a lump sum, and the project manager runs the construction phase on the client's behalf. HMG Construction Management SA provides that project management, alongside your architect or on its own, from the plans to the end of the works.
What does each of them do?
The architect
Designs the project, shapes its architecture and draws up the plans. Often files the permit application and, depending on the contract, may also oversee construction.
The general contractor
Delivers the entire building for a lump sum and picks its own subcontractors. The client signs a single construction contract and knows the price fairly early.
The project manager
Runs the construction phase for the client. Tenders each trade separately, coordinates the contractors, checks quality, time and invoices, then organises acceptance of the works. In Geneva this role is called direction des travaux.
Other terms are used too. Maître d'œuvre refers to whoever designs and oversees the work for the client, and project management is the on-site part of that role. A delegated client, or maître d'ouvrage délégué, acts in the owner's name, whereas an owner's representative (in French), or AMO, advises and protects the owner without necessarily running the site. Site coordination, finally, is the day-to-day organisation of the trades, one of the project manager's tasks.
What are the strengths and limits of each option?
No option is better in every case. Each meets a different need.
- Architect with a full assignment. The strength is continuity between design and site, with a single author for the project. The point to check is exactly what the construction phase covers in the contract.
- General contractor. Its strengths are a single construction contract, a lump sum known early and one party answerable for all the works. In return, the choice of subcontractors is its own, and changes requested along the way are negotiated with it.
- Independent project manager. Every trade is tendered, the client keeps control over the choice of contractors and has a representative with no financial ties to them. In return, the client signs several contracts and must take the decisions put to them in good time.
What does each option cost?
There is no rate that fits every project, because the cost depends on the scale of the works and the scope of the assignment. With a general contractor, coordination is included in the lump sum. With an architect and a project manager, each is paid for their own assignment.
The principle is straightforward. A firm that specialises in project management usually costs less for that assignment, because it is the only thing it does. The architect concentrates on design, HMG on the site, and each is paid for what they know best. Our article on the cost of construction project management in Geneva explains this further.
Geneva procedures, whichever option you choose
The arrangement you choose does not change the cantonal rules. Building permits are issued by the Office des autorisations de construire (OAC), the cantonal permit office. Under the ordinary procedure, a full application, or DD, must with rare exceptions be filed by a professional on the MPQ list, the cantonal register of qualified building professionals, as the page Je prépare ma demande d'autorisation de construire (in French) explains. A private owner may file a fast-track APA application alone, although the Canton advises using a registered agent.
The file is prepared and submitted on the AC-Démat platform (in French). HMG draws up the plans and files the permit application as an agent registered on the Geneva MPQ list (mandataires professionnellement qualifiés, the cantonal register of qualified building professionals). The firm is not an architectural practice. Where a project calls for substantial architectural design, the client's architect remains its author, and HMG works with them.
Who should you approach first?
There are two simple ways to organise your project.
- One contact from the plans to handover. You give HMG the plans, the permit application, the cost estimate, the choice of contractors and the management of the site, under a single agreement.
- Your architect and HMG together. The architect is responsible for the design and the permit, and HMG takes charge of the site once the permit is granted, in close contact with the architect.
If you prefer a general contractor, HMG can also support you as owner's representative (in French), looking after your interests in your dealings with it.
How to choose, and where HMG fits in
- You want a lump sum fixed early and a single contract. A general contractor meets that need, and HMG can advise you alongside it.
- You want to choose each contractor and follow costs item by item. An independent project manager makes that possible.
- Your project has a strong architectural dimension. The architect is its designer, and HMG can handle construction with them.
- You lack the time to follow the works, or you live far away. A project manager represents you on site, as our guide to following your site remotely explains.
Founded in Geneva in 2014, HMG has managed six storey additions to apartment buildings, seven hotel renovations and five villas, as well as restaurants, clinics and offices.
The steps with a project manager
- Defining the project, with your architect or with HMG.
- Plans and permit application filed by an agent on the MPQ list.
- Cost estimate by item under the CFC, the Swiss construction cost classification.
- Tendering, comparison of bids and choice of contractors.
- Managing construction to SIA standards, with schedule and cost control.
- Acceptance of the works and final account.
Projects managed by HMG
Frequently asked questions on choosing between architect, general contractor and project manager in Geneva
Do I have to use an architect in Geneva?
Not to run a building site. Under the ordinary procedure, however, the permit application must with rare exceptions be filed by a professional on the MPQ list, according to the official page (in French). For a project that calls for substantial architectural design, an architect remains the right person to talk to.
Can I keep my architect and hand only the site to a project management firm?
Yes, it is a common arrangement. The design stays the architect's, who also obtained the permit, while the project management firm delivers it on site in liaison with them. Each works in their own field.
Is a general contractor more expensive?
Not necessarily. It offers a lump sum known early and a single party answerable for the works, which has real value. The right choice depends on how much price certainty you need, whether you want to pick each contractor and how much time you have.
What is a delegated client?
A person or firm that acts in the owner's name for the decisions entrusted to it, known in Geneva as maître d'ouvrage délégué. A project manager runs the construction phase and coordinates the contractors. The two roles can complement each other on the same project.
Is HMG an architectural practice?
No. HMG is an independent construction project management firm. It draws up plans and files permit applications as an agent on the MPQ list, and works with architects as partners.
Related guides and pages
Request a call back
Describe your project in a few lines. HMG calls you back within 24 hours.




