HMGHMGConstruction ManagementSA, Geneva, Switzerland
FR
+41 22 552 08 22
info@hmgconstruction.ch
Article

When should you bring in a cost consultant, and what goes into a CFC cost estimate?

Planning building work? Apartment, house or building renovation, a new storey or a roof extension, running the project is our job.

Bring in a construction cost consultant as soon as your project takes shape, before the permit application and the tenders. At HMG Construction Management SA, this costing is part of the assignment. The overall estimate sorts every cost by the CFC, the Swiss construction cost classification, so bids can be compared and the budget held until the final account.

By Haïtam Mennana, HMG Construction Management SA, registered MPQ agent

What does a construction cost consultant do?

A cost consultant, called an économiste de la construction in French-speaking Switzerland, answers one plain question, what the project will cost, and then makes sure that answer stays right until the last payment. They work for the building owner, not for a contractor. Their job is not to sell work but to say what it ought to cost and to spot anything that drifts away from that.

In practice, they estimate the cost of the works from the drawings, break it down into items, prepare the basis for the tenders, compare the bids received, track spending during construction and draw up the final account. The owner gets figures to decide on at every point where a decision costs money.

When should the cost consultant come in?

The SIA 112 standard, the Swiss model for building services, splits a project into six phases, from setting objectives to operating the building. Costing runs through almost every phase in which money is spent or committed.

  1. Preliminary studies (phase 2). A first order of magnitude shows whether the project fits the envelope you have in mind, before you pay for detailed drawings.
  2. Project design (phase 3). The overall estimate is drawn up from the design drawings, item by item. It becomes the reference budget.
  3. Tendering (phase 4). Contractors' bids are compared with the estimate line by line, which brings out omissions and unusual prices.
  4. Construction (phase 5). Committed costs, extra works and invoices are tracked in the same structure until the final account.

The earlier the costing, the cheaper it is to adjust the project. Once contractors are appointed, every change has a price. Each phase is explained in our guide to the SIA phases of a building project.

What is the CFC?

The CFC (Code des frais de construction) is the classification of costs by item used across Switzerland for estimates and final accounts. Every item of spending has its place in it, from the land to the external works, by way of the structure, the building services and the finishes.

Its value lies in continuity. The same breakdown is used for the overall estimate, the tenders, the contracts, cost tracking and the final account. At each stage you are comparing figures sorted in the same way, so a gap shows up straight away under the item concerned.

What does an overall cost estimate contain?

A sound estimate is more than a total. It says what has been counted and what has not.

  • The cost of the works, item by item under the CFC, with the main quantities and the price assumptions used.
  • Consultants' fees, such as project management, engineers and specialists, depending on the project.
  • Other project costs, for example those linked to the permit, utility connections or site insurance.
  • A contingency for the unexpected, shown as such rather than spread across the items.
  • Exclusions, meaning what the estimate does not cover, such as furniture or equipment chosen later.
  • The date and the reference documents, so you know which drawings the figure was based on.

The estimate remains an estimate. The price of the works is fixed later by the contracts signed with the contractors, after the tendering described on our page on contractor selection and tendering in Geneva.

How HMG uses the estimate on site

At HMG, the overall estimate is not a document filed away once the permit is granted. It becomes the dashboard for the works.

  • Tenders are issued by CFC item, so each bid can be set directly against the estimate.
  • Extra works are priced and put to the owner before they are carried out.
  • Every invoice is checked and allocated to its item before payment.
  • The owner receives regular reports on committed costs and the forecast final cost.
  • The final account follows the same breakdown, which makes the comparison with the starting budget immediate.

Other ways of keeping to budget are set out in our guide on avoiding budget and schedule overruns, and the full service is described on the page Économiste de la construction à Genève (in French).

Who should you approach first?

There are two ways of organising the work, and both give you a budget that is tracked from start to finish.

  • You hand the whole project to HMG. The firm draws up the plans, files the permit application as an agent registered on the Geneva MPQ list (mandataires professionnellement qualifiés, the cantonal register of qualified building professionals), works out the cost, appoints the contractors, sets the schedules and manages the works to SIA standards through to completion.
  • You work with an architect. The architect designs the project and obtains the permit, then HMG takes over in collaboration with them, prepares or adopts the overall estimate on the basis of the approved drawings and manages construction.

Either way, one estimate remains the reference from tendering to the final account.

A selection of HMG projects

Frequently asked questions about cost consultants in Geneva

Is an overall cost estimate a guaranteed price?

No. It is an estimate based on drawings and price assumptions. The price becomes firm with the contractors' contracts, and the estimate is then used to check that those contracts stay within budget.

How does an overall estimate differ from a contractor's quote?

A contractor's quote covers that firm's own work and reflects its interests. The overall estimate covers the whole project, every contractor and every cost, and it is prepared for the owner.

Do I need a cost consultant for a small renovation?

As soon as several contractors are involved, costing by item avoids overlaps and gaps between them. For an apartment renovation, for instance, HMG prepares this costing as part of its project management service (in French).

Why sort costs by CFC item rather than by contractor?

Because contractors can change while the items stay the same. Sorting by CFC lets you compare several bids for the same work and follow an item even if two contractors work on it in turn.

Can the cost consultant and the project manager be the same firm?

Yes, and that is how HMG works. Whoever prepared the estimate knows every assumption behind it, which makes checking bids and invoices during construction easier.

Related guides and pages

Your project

Request a call back

Describe your project in a few lines. HMG calls you back within 24 hours.

+41 22 552 08 22

CallRequest a call back